Refuse To Choose: How To Do Everything You Love
Sunday, August 22nd, 2010I just read the very interesting Refuse to Choose by Barbara Sher (recommended to me by Paul Strobl of Confide Coaching). It’s about the types of people she calls “scanners” (as opposed to “divers”); people who would rather survey the whole horizon than go diving as deep as they can in one spot. She calls them scanners, I call them polymaths, but they’re very similar.
The copy I picked up at the library had the subtitle A Revolutionary Program for Doing Everything That You Love. I thought this was a little odd, as I didn’t see why doing everything you love would be such a big challenge, aside from productivity issues. Like Nike said, just do it.
But when I looked it up on Amazon, I came across the alternate subtitle “Use All of Your Interests, Passions, and Hobbies to Create the Life and Career of Your Dreams.” I found this much more intriguing, though perhaps overly ambitious. But it made me wonder if it was just a different subtitle, or a completely revised edition.
And now I’ve written yet another subtitle in my headline, so I’m not exactly helping. Anyway, my comments are based on the version I read.
The main thing I got out of this book was that it’s OK to be a scanner, it’s just how we’re wired and not something we should try to suppress, and in fact it’s a good thing. Which I already knew, of course, but it was nice to see a recognized life coach saying so and talking about her clients who have successfully pursued their diverse interests.
One example of how she shows that scanners are OK: the false stigma of quitting. Many scanners get very frustrated with themselves for not being able to finish what they set out to do. Barbara explains why this is not a sign of failure, but a sign of having goals that are achieved before a project appears to be done. When a bee gets nectar from a flower and then moves on to the next one, do you call it a quitter for not sticking around?
I especially like how she separately addresses all the different types of scanners. From her experiences with working with so many scanners, she’s found that they don’t all fit the same pattern. Instead, there are two broad groups – cyclical scanners, who keep returning to the same interests, and sequential scanners, who don’t. Then these groups are further broken down into nine types:
- Cyclical Scanners
- The Double Agent
- The Sybil
- The Plate Spinner
- Sequential Scanners
- The Serial Specialist
- The Serial Master
- The Jack-of-All-Trades
- The Wanderer
- The Sampler
- The High-Speed Indecisive
She talks about the unique challenges of each type, and goes into practical methods for managing your time, staying focused, and doing what you want to do.
However, don’t assume you’ll fit neatly into one category. I identified myself as a combination of the Sybil, Serial Master, Jack-of-All-Trades, Wanderer, and Sampler, thereby spanning more than half the categories. Oh well, I guess I’m difficult.
Hats off to Barbara Sher for standing up for scanners. When the world demands that you choose a path, what is a scanner to do? Simple: refuse to choose!



